geodbear, can we get a clarification on the H2H standings again? From just a quick scan over the results you posted, Dutch had the exact same regular season record as cumulative season record. That's impossible because he had to have at least participated in 2 playoff matchups, meaning at least 18 W/L must have been added to his cumulative record.
Say a manager finished the regular season with a record of 100-89 (note that it must add up to 189 total W/L). He goes 5-4, 5-3-1, and 7-2 in his three playoff matchups. His cumulative record would then be 117-98-1.
Once you confirm them I'll go ahead and check the calculations to make sure they're right.