Consensus Rankings

[KalElen]

Rules of the list - If you want to participate, just reply to this thread with the player you think should be ranked next on the draft list
- Rank the NBA players based on a Single-Season, Traditional 9-catagory Fantasy League (either H2H or Roto)
- Each player needs 6 votes to be ranked (1-12), 5 votes to be ranked (13-36), 4 votes to be ranked (37-84), and 3 votes to be ranked (84+)
- Every time you vote, post player's name and number of votes (by incrementing previous voters sum of votes by one)
- Each member can only vote for one player at a time and should hold off voting again until his choice is picked. Everyone is free to change their vote at any time, but he has to clearly mark it by making a new post where he'll subtract a vote from his previous choice and add it to his new choice
- If you are the final deciding voter for a particular player, you should bold or in some other way mark your post so it is easier for me and mods to keep track of it and add player to the 1st post. after that you can vote again for the next player


List:
1. Kevin Durant
2. Chris Paul
3. LeBron James
4. Dirk Nowitzki
5. Dwyane Wade
6. Kobe Bryant
7. Danny Granger
8. Stephen Curry
9. Pau Gasol
10. Deron Williams
11. Amar'e Stoudemire
12. David Lee
13. Brook Lopez
14. Josh Smith
15. Carmelo Anthony
16. Jason Kidd
17. Gerald Wallace
18. Al Horford
19. Chauncey Billups

[KalElen]

kevin durant




i'm not sure where this should go. maybe it should go to leftovers, but i'll leave that to mods to decide

[Rounders Block]

Kal let's keep this all to one thread so Leftovers doesn't get cluttered. Once a guy hits his quota to be ranked, the next guy will just nominate a new guy for the next spot on the rankings.

#1 - Kevin Durant (2)

[KalElen]

Kal let's keep this all to one thread so Leftovers doesn't get cluttered. Once a guy hits his quota to be ranked, the next guy will just nominate a new guy for the next spot on the rankings.

#1 - Kevin Durant (2)

no prob. keeping it all in one thread might prove to be little more work, but you are wright about not wanting to clutter the sub-board. it would probably be a good idea for everybody who votes to post current number of votes for his choice (like you did) and the moment his player qualifies for the list he submits another vote for the next player. we'll keep 1st post updated to show players already ranked. i'll edit 1st post with modified instructions

[geodbear]

#1:
Kevin Durant (2)
Chris Paul (1)

I'm going to go against conventional wisdom here and put in a nod for Chris Paul. I don't think it's as clear cut for #1 as it's been made out. Plus the Collison trade removes some doubt too.

[RedHopeful]

#1:
Kevin Durant (3)
Chris Paul (1)

For the first pick it doesn't matter, but we need to determine whether this is for H2H or Roto rankings.

[Fenris-77]

I'd still take Durant at 1 and Paul at either two or three, depending on format. I'd call this for roto if I had a choice since that takes overall injury potential into more account. So..

#1:
Kevin Durant (4)
Chris Paul (1)

[deadshot11]

#1:
Kevin Durant (5)
Chris Paul (1)

[baller crimson]

#2
Chris Paul (1)

#1
Kevin Durant (6)

[Fenris-77]

#2
Chris Paul (2)

..............

#1
Kevin Durant (6)