Fantasy Basketball Cafe Forums

by **MiNdHaBiTs** » Thu Nov 08, 2012 6:55 am

10 team category league

Bynum Amare Knight for Noah Boozer Kmart

Im the commisioner and want to be fair and leave it to vote but i set it at 6 votes to veto and not sure if it'll get the 6 votes.

Is it lopsided? If so should i step in and commissioner veto?

by **CatJ** » Thu Nov 08, 2012 10:59 am

No veto in here for me. One can consider Amare will come back booming which balances the trade pretty well.
So it's far from a veto to me.

by **MiNdHaBiTs** » Thu Nov 08, 2012 3:40 pm

The thing is Bynum went in first round round Noah fifth Amare Boozer 7th Knight Kmart 9th. Which means this trade is basically a 5th round pick for a first.

by **Vicious_Machine** » Fri Nov 09, 2012 5:45 am

hate it but I wouldnt veto it. Maybe the Bynum owner thinks Bynum is going to miss 2-3 months as well. I still think he can get more for sure. But unless there is some reason for you to suspect collusion, i personally would not veto it.

I know somebody who traded Granger for Hinrich in a h2h (Your thinking is basically saying its a 3rd rounder for a 13th rounder, but a lot has changed since then). In our league, the guy was thinking, he essentially preferred ANYBODY over an empty slot in a h2h.

Still think eeww cause its Bynum; but credit to the owner GM, he is trading for two injured guys who's value is SUPER low.

You cant penalize him just cause he traded hot guys for cold guys while you were sleeping.

No veto unless you can prove collusion.